Little Cups, Big Benefits: A Parent’s Guide to Milk Options

Key Nutrients Ages 1 – 5 Need from Milk

Milk plays a critical role in the diet of young children aged 1 to 5 years, providing essential nutrients necessary for growth, development, and overall health. The key nutrients found in milk include:

  • Calcium: Supports strong bones and teeth development.
  • Vitamin D: Works with calcium to enhance bone health and immune function.
  • Protein: Essential for growth, tissue repair, and muscle development.
  • Fats: Vital for brain development, energy, and the absorption of fat-soluble vitamins (A, D, E, and K).
  • Vitamin A: Promotes eye health, immune function, and skin health.
  • B Vitamins (Riboflavin, B12): Help convert food into energy and support the nervous system.
  • Phosphorus: Works with calcium to build strong bones and teeth.
  • Potassium: Maintains fluid balance and helps with muscle and nerve function

Snapshot of Milk Options and Their Nutritional Benefits

Below is a breakdown of various milk and milk alternatives, along with the nutrients they provide:

 

"A half-gallon carton of Kemps 1% lowfat milk with a blue label, featuring the Kemps logo and an image of a farm scene in the background."

Cow's Milk

  • What It Is: Milk produced by cows, the most common type of milk consumed globally.
  • Nutrients: High in calcium, protein, phosphorus, potassium, vitamin B12, vitamin D (if fortified), and fat (whole milk).
  • Options: Whole (full-fat), 2%, 1%, and skim (fat-free).
  • Notes: Whole milk is recommended for ages 1-2 due to its fat content for brain development.
A carton of Meyenberg Goat Milk with a purple and white design, featuring the brand name and an illustration of a goat."
  • What It Is: Milk from goats, often easier to digest for some children due to its protein structure.
  • Nutrients: Comparable to cow’s milk in calcium, protein, and vitamins A and B2. It naturally contains less lactose.
  • Notes: Should be fortified with vitamin D to meet daily requirements.
A bottle of Ripple pea milk with a beige label, featuring the brand name in bold letters and a clean, modern design.
  • What It Is: Plant-based milk made from yellow peas.
  • Nutrients: High in protein (similar to cow’s milk), calcium (if fortified), iron, and omega-3 fatty acids.
  • Notes: A good option for children with allergies to dairy, nuts, and soy.
A carton of Silk Soy Milk with a blue and white label, featuring the Silk logo and an image of a splash of soy milk with soybeans.
  • What It Is: Plant-based milk made from soybeans.
  • Nutrients: High in protein, calcium (if fortified), vitamin D (if fortified), and potassium.
  • Notes: Nutritionally closest to cow’s milk and a suitable alternative for children with dairy allergies.

Current Recommendations for Children Ages 1 - 5

The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and other health organizations provide the following guidelines for milk and milk alternatives for children aged 1 to 5:

Ages 1-2 Years

  • Milk Type: Whole cow’s milk is recommended due to its higher fat content for brain development.
  • Daily Amount: 16-24 ounces (2-3 cups) per day.
  • Alternatives: If cow’s milk is not an option, fortified soy milk is the preferred alternative due to its comparable nutrient profile.

Ages 2-5 Years

  • Milk Type: Switch to low-fat (1%) or fat-free (skim) milk to limit saturated fat intake.
  • Daily Amount: 16-20 ounces (2-2.5 cups) per day.
  • Alternatives: Fortified soy milk remains the closest substitute. Other plant-based options (pea milk, nut milks, oat milk, etc.) can be included but should be fortified with calcium and vitamin D.

Additional Notes

  • Calcium Intake: Aim for 700 mg/day (1-3 years) and 1,000 mg/day (4-5 years) through milk, dairy products, or fortified alternatives.
  • Vitamin D: Ensure 600 IU/day, primarily through fortified milk or supplements.
  • Protein: Children require approximately 13-19 grams of protein daily, which can come from milk, dairy alternatives, and other food sources.
  • Watch for Added Sugars: Opt for unsweetened versions of plant-based milk to avoid excess sugar intake.

Big Picture

Milk and milk alternatives play a crucial role in meeting the nutritional needs of children aged 1 – 5. Cow’s milk remains the gold standard, but fortified soy milk and other options can meet nutrient requirements for children with allergies or dietary preferences. Parents should focus on providing a balance of protein, calcium, and vitamin D to support their child’s healthy growth and development.

By: Hannah Colby, RD, LD, CLS with Aitkin County Public Health